The first time I went with L and we both got the Strawberry Shortcake Cookies. These were wonderful, one of the best cookies I have had that didn't involve chocolate in it. It was moist, but I would have preferred a little bit more strawberry.
My 3rd time G and I decided to try 2 cupcakes.
The second was the Peanut Butter Cup (Rich chocolate cake filled and frosted with our peanut butter cream cheese frosting and topped with peanut butter cup wedges and edged in crushed peanuts and chocolate chips). Another let down :( Dry, flavorless cake and the icing was a very interesting consistency for butter-cream but I am not an expert on icing, so it could have been normal.
*descriptions of the cupcakes from the crumbs website*