The past couple of times I tried to go here they were closed, they are apparently closed on Sundays and Mondays-note to self. This past trip to Cayuga was pretty short so we didn't do a lot of cooking. I couldn't find any sort of menu online, so hopefully this helps people out.
We got one large pizza with ricotta and ham. This combination was delicious, the ricotta and ham were both good quality, I was particularly impressed with the ricotta.
The other large pizza was 1/2 cheese 1/2 spinach and onions. Another good pizza and combination.
I was really impressed with New York Pizzeria. Great quality pizza and toppings. Both pizzas totaled $40. Not bad to feed a family of 6 and have leftovers the next day. On average each person at 2 slices. Wish I had this kind of place near my house.
2 W Main